Ever Considered What Would Happen if Gandalf Fought Dumbledore? If Smaug Fought Toothless?
Here at MiddleEarth.Vs, we use complicated stuff like math to try to sort it out.
A lot of VS debates are composed of powerscaling, overreliance on dialogue, and at best some poorly-done calcs. We try not to do that. We try to apply the scientific method, in the manner of Saxton and Wong. As of now all of us are high schoolers, so we're not that knowledgable. Don't take our word for things. However, if you disagree with us, at least try to explain why.
Alatar the Blue
dutch09
Site owner
Middle-earth consultant—has read most of Tolkien's books, many of them more than once
Dune consultant—has read all the first five books at least once
Combat consultant—sword nerd
​
I was inspired to create this website by StarDestroyer.Net, where Mike Wong, an engineer, broke down the Star Wars vs Star Trek debate.
Writer
Star Wars consultant—has seen all the films and most of the shows
Wings Of Fire consultant—has read all the books
Fablehaven and Dragonwatch consultant—has read all the books
How To Train Your Dragon consultant—watched and studied all the films
Sea warfare consultant—sea warfare nerd
Raith Sienar
EmperorHero
Galadriel
bookworm057
Writer
Middle-earth consultant—has read most of Tolkien's books, many of them more than once
Pirates of the Caribbean consultant—big fan of the films, loves all three of them
